At a recent meal held by my fiancé Jacob’s family, my SIL surprised me with a spontaneous gesture. After an enthusiastic toast, she handed me a huge plastic bag containing her wedding attire from two years ago. With everyone watching, she said that this was her wedding gift to me and she hoped I would wear it at my wedding. The unexpected and public nature of the gift made me feel uncomfortable and torn, as I had always wanted to wear my mother’s wedding gown, which had been passed down through generations in my family.
As I struggled to communicate, my refusal to wear SIL’s outfit triggered an angry outburst from her and a severe reaction from my in-laws. My fiancé, who showed no support for me, gave me severe criticism and said that I was embarrassing him. Despite my attempts to explain the deep personal significance of my mother’s outfit, he rejected my feelings and supported his family. Now I’m thinking if I should have handled the matter better and if my response was inappropriate.
via Reddit: r/AITAH
image credits: Hussein Altameemi
image credits: Logan Rhoads
image credits: RDNE Stock project
Read more info on Reddit: r/AITAH
During a stressful family dinner, a woman is caught off guard when her sister-in-law gives her a wedding dress from her wedding, expecting her to wear it. The woman, who had always intended to wear her mother’s beloved wedding dress, struggles to articulate her emotions, resulting in a serious rift with her fiancé and his family. Accused of generating a disturbance, she wonders if her refusal was harsh and whether she could have handled the matter differently.
Readers are unhappy with her fiance’s family and behavior, which sparked a debate.
0 thoughts on “AITA for refusing to wear the wedding dress my SIL gave to me as a “wedding gift””